The Lebanonization of Iraq? So, I've been thinking lately about Iraq, and I keep noticing similarities to Israel's war in Lebanon, or Operation Peace for Galilee, which started in 1982. Obviously, there is serious destabilization in the country, which was expected, and splintering along ethnic lines, which also was expected, and a growing resentment among ordinary Iraqis for the American presence (which I expected, although I'm not sure the administration did) which is similar to what happened to Israel in '82. Basically, Israel made the mistake of not getting out fast enough. They tried not only to destroy the PLO, which they succeed brilliantly in doing (it was only resurrected at the hands of the Leftists who signed the Oslo Treaty ten years later) but also to permanently change the political situation there, which was impossible to do. I think America might be attempting a similar fools game. We might want to face the fact that Iraq was never a real country in the first place, it was post-colonial aberration cobbled together by imperialist powers and held together by a totalitarian dictatorship of the ugliest kind. The best move might be to partition the country into three, its Kurdish section in the North and the Shiite portion in the South being independent of the Sunni Arab center. Obviously, the biggest obstacle to this is the desire of all three groups to have a share in Iraq's oil revenues and the problem of ethnic minority groups, but I think these can be worked out into some sort of working status quo.
Thursday, November 13, 2003
About Me
- Name: benjamin
- Location: Tel Aviv, Israel
Benjamin Kerstein is an Israeli-American writer, editor, and novelist.
Michael J. Totten, the prize-winning author of The Road to Fatima Gate, has called him "one of the finest American-Israeli authors of his generation."
Jay Nordlinger of the National Review has referred to his work as "some of the most intelligent, clearest, most honest writing I have read in a long time."
He lives in Tel Aviv.
Previous Posts
- Buying Jeans in the Promised Land. On a lighter n...
- Bill the Butcher on Bush's Trip to England. Appar...
- The Historiography of the Historians. I'm about tw...
- Imposing A Status Quo. Had an interesting meeting...
- Fifty-nine percent of Europeans say that Israel is...
- Strike The other looming issue is the possible ge...
- Elections The big story today is the municipal el...
- BACK AFTER A LONG ABSCENCE Apologies, gentle read...
- Beilin-Abed Rabbo is a conscious effort – by a man...
- The unofficial draft peace agreement cobbled toget...
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home